The woman with the rock in her rice bin

FIELD NOTES · MIND

The woman with the rock in her rice bin

Social isolation raises mortality by roughly 29%. Chronic loneliness by 26%. Fifteen cigarettes a day is the comparison people use. What that looks like on the floor, and what to actually do.

There is a woman I used to see on Tuesdays. She came into the day-care center at nine, on the shuttle, and by ten she’d have told me about a rock the size of a coin she’d found in the corner of her rice bin that morning, and how it must have come from the field where her father grew rice fifty years ago, and how strange it was that a rock could travel that far and then just sit there in her kitchen waiting for her.

She lived alone. Her husband had died eleven years earlier. Her daughter lived in Yokohama with a job and a schedule and two children. On Tuesdays, we were the people she spoke to. Sometimes I think about her when the research on loneliness comes across my desk.

The numbers, if you haven’t seen them lately, are worse than you might imagine. Julianne Holt-Lunstad’s team at Brigham Young ran a meta-analysis of 148 studies covering more than three hundred thousand people, and the finding held: people with weaker social ties die earlier. Social isolation raises mortality by about 29%. Loneliness itself — the feeling, not just the fact — by about 26%. The comparison people quote is fifteen cigarettes a day, and while that’s a rough analogy, the direction is right.

What’s happening in the body is not mysterious.

When someone feels chronically alone, their brain treats it as a threat. Cortisol, the alarm hormone, stays up. Short-term cortisol is fine; it’s how a person jumps out of the way of a car. Chronic cortisol is a slow corrosion. Blood pressure runs high. Inflammation runs high. The immune system starts making bad calls.

Sleep is the second thing that gives way. The lonely brain sleeps light, because at some deep level it thinks it needs to keep watch. A night of light sleep is manageable. A year of light sleep begins to eat cognition.

And here is the one I find hardest to talk about with families. A large Finnish cohort found that middle-aged people who were socially isolated had roughly double the risk of dementia later in life. Talking to someone stimulates the brain. Days without any conversation are days the brain is not being used. The organ we most want to keep is the organ that requires other people to work.

What to actually do

I want to be careful here, because most articles on loneliness end with a list that assumes joining a hiking club is easy. It isn’t. When you’ve been quiet for a long time, walking into a room full of strangers is more effort than the room understands. So start smaller than the internet tells you to.

Three conversations a week is a target most people can hit. That is the person at the register at the convenience store. It is a two-minute phone call with a niece. It is a nod and a “good morning” to whoever waters the plants on the corner. None of these count as a friendship. All of them count as a use of the muscles that let you make one.

After that, community centers. Every Japanese municipality runs classes and clubs for older residents. Poetry groups, photography groups, cooking classes, the ubiquitous morning exercise groups. If walking in feels like too much, ask if you can just observe for a session. Nobody will send you away.

Volunteering is the surprising one. There is a real body of research showing that doing something for someone else raises subjective well-being more reliably than being on the receiving end of care does. Teaching children a game you knew as a child. Carrying somebody’s groceries the last block to their door. The osekkai tradition — the meddlesome kindness that gets a bad name in Japanese sitcoms — turns out to be quietly medicinal.

A word about pets. Dogs and cats reduce loneliness. If a full-time animal is more than your body can handle now, cat cafés exist. So do the volunteer dog-walking programs run by local shelters. There is more than one way to bring a warm creature into a quiet room.

Two things to be careful of

Screens are not enough on their own. Facebook, LINE groups, whatever comes next — they are useful, but studies keep finding that if online contact replaces in-person contact, loneliness gets worse, not better. Face-to-face, or voice-to-voice at minimum, most of the time. Text and posts as supplement.

And solitude is not loneliness. Some people love their own company. That is different. Loneliness is the ache of wanting more contact than you have. If you don’t have the ache, you don’t have the problem. This piece is for the people who do.

One more thing

I don’t know what happened to the woman with the rock in her rice bin. Her daughter moved her closer to Yokohama a few years ago, and my old center lost track. I like to think somebody there listens on Tuesdays about the rock.

Aging without company is not something to accept. It is one of the actual things — alongside food, movement, sleep — that determines how many of your years are healthy ones. Send one message today. Or say good morning to somebody on the way to the corner.

References

  • Holt-Lunstad J, Smith TB, Baker M, Harris T, Stephenson D. Loneliness and social isolation as risk factors for mortality: a meta-analytic review. Perspectives on Psychological Science, 2015;10(2):227–237.
  • Sundström A, Adolfsson AN, Nordin M, Adolfsson R. Loneliness increases the risk of all-cause dementia and Alzheimer’s disease. J Gerontol B Psychol Sci Soc Sci, 2020;75(5):919–926.
  • Cacioppo JT, Hawkley LC. Perceived social isolation and cognition. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 2009;13(10):447–454.
  • U.S. Surgeon General’s Advisory on the Healing Effects of Social Connection and Community, 2023.
— Kiyotaka Hasegawa
Still Walking at 100 book cover

📖 New book by the author of this site

Still Walking at 100: How Japan’s Elders Stay Steady on Their Feet

Kindle $3.99 · free with Kindle Unlimited

Learn more

Comments

コメントを残す

メールアドレスが公開されることはありません。 が付いている欄は必須項目です